Situation ranking
Cyber Essentials software for a supplier whose contract, or Defence Cyber Certification, requires Cyber Essentials Plus
For a supplier whose contract, or Defence Cyber Certification, requires Cyber Essentials Plus, CyberSmart ranks first at 5.85 out of 10 and Sprinto second at 5.75 (read 18 Nov 2026). Scytale ranks 6th of 10 at 4.80. Scytale publishes no price, and sells its expert services separately from its plans, with no certification body named for Cyber Essentials. CyberSmart is ahead mainly on guided route to the certificate: 7 against Scytale's 1 at a weight of 25 percent.
The short answer
This buyer holds a contract, or is bidding for one, that names Cyber Essentials Plus, often through Defence Cyber Certification Levels 2 and 3. The technical audit decides the outcome, so device, patch and MFA evidence and a body that runs the audit weigh most, with Plus readiness at 35 per cent.
The technical audit decides the outcome: device, patch and MFA evidence and a body that runs the audit matter most.
Which platform ranks first for a supplier whose contract, or Defence Cyber Certification, requires Cyber Essentials Plus?
| Rank | Platform | Score out of 10 | Route line: Questionnaire Assessor Plus audit Renewal | Control themes, of 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CyberSmart | 5.85 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 2 | Sprinto | 5.75 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 3joint | IT Governance | 5.50 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 3joint | Secureframe | 5.50 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 5 | Thoropass | 4.90 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 6 | Scytale | 4.80 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 7 | Vanta | 4.70 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 8 | Drata | 4.65 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 9 | ISMS.online | 4.18 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal | |
| 10 | Scrut Automation | 4.10 | QuestionnaireAssessorPlus auditRenewal |
Not ranked
- Comp AI: Cyber Essentials not supported on its pages, read 18 Nov 2026. Score for reference 3.88, no rank.
- Hicomply: Cyber Essentials listed only as partial on its pages, read 18 Nov 2026. Score for reference 3.15, no rank.
- DataGuard: Cyber Essentials not supported on its pages, read 18 Nov 2026. Score for reference 2.63, no rank.
- Delve: Cyber Essentials not supported on its pages, read 18 Nov 2026. Score for reference 2.40, no rank.
How are the criteria weighted for this buyer?
| Criterion | This view | Main | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guided route to the certificate | 25% | 25% | 0 |
| Plus readiness | 35% | 20% | +15 |
| Reuse beyond Cyber Essentials | 5% | 15% | -10 |
| Continuous monitoring of the five control themes | 15% | 15% | 0 |
| AI that does the work under control | 5% | 10% | -5 |
| Pricing transparency | 10% | 10% | 0 |
| Proof | 5% | 5% | 0 |
Who should pick what?
- CyberSmart (5.85): CyberSmart ranks 1st at 5.85: it scores 7 on guided route, Plus readiness and monitoring, and says on its own pages that it is an IASME licensed Certification Body running the Plus audit in-house. Sprinto ranks 2nd at 5.75, scoring 7 on Plus readiness, reuse and monitoring from its endpoint agent and scanner integrations. IT Governance and Secureframe are joint 3rd at 5.50, the first with assessors it says are its own and a published Plus price, the second with 7 on Plus readiness and monitoring.
- Sprinto (5.75) is the alternative: its strongest weighted criterion here is Plus readiness, 7 of 10 at 35 percent.
- Scytale (6th, 4.80): its strongest weighted criterion here is Plus readiness, 7 of 10 at 35 percent.
What would change this ranking?
- CyberSmart leads Sprinto by 0.10. A fall of 0.5 points on guided route to the certificate (from 7, weight 25 percent) would put Sprinto ahead. The score rests on the pages linked below, so a change on them would move it. Sources: 1 2 3
- Scytale would draw level with CyberSmart (a gap of 1.05) by gaining 3 points on Plus readiness, from 7 to 10 at 35 percent of the weight. That criterion rewards device, patch, MFA and account evidence for the technical audit, and vulnerability scanning or testing. Sources: 1 2 3
- The next nearest single move for Scytale is guided route to the certificate: 4.5 points (from 1), at 25 percent of the weight. Sources: 1 2
Sources
- CyberSmart: Cyber Essentials cybersmart.co.uk/frameworks/cyber-essentials/, read 18 Nov 2026
- CyberSmart: Active Protect cybersmart.co.uk/products/active-protect/, read 18 Nov 2026
- CyberSmart: plans cybersmart.co.uk/plans/, read 18 Nov 2026
- Sprinto: Cyber Essentials framework sprinto.com/frameworks/cyber-essentials/, read 18 Nov 2026
- Sprinto: monitors and manual inputs docs.sprinto.com/monitors/dr.-sprinto-and-manual-inputs..., read 18 Nov 2026
- Sprinto: ISO 27001 framework sprinto.com/frameworks/iso-27001/, read 18 Nov 2026
- Sprinto: Sprinto AI sprinto.com/sprinto-ai/, read 18 Nov 2026
- Sprinto: pricing sprinto.com/pricing/, read 18 Nov 2026
- Sprinto: customers sprinto.com/customers/, read 18 Nov 2026
- IT Governance: Cyber Essentials grcsolutions.io/cyber-essentials/, read 18 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 18 Nov 2026.